Article: Will Linux phones become a viable alternative to the Android/iOS duopoly?
#1
I wrote in-depth article about whether Linux phones will become a viable alternative to the Android/iOS duopoly:

https://amosbbatto.wordpress.com/2026/10...ternative/

You can also read it as a PDF or ODT document (see the links in the article), which look much better in my opinion. I hate the styling in WordPress.

I'm pretty critical of all the Linux mobile device makers, but I also see a lot of hope for the future.
Feedback is welcome.
  Reply
#2
(10-07-2026, 07:37 PM)amosbatto Wrote: I wrote in-depth article about whether Linux phones will become a viable alternative to the Android/iOS duopoly:

https://amosbbatto.wordpress.com/2026/10...ternative/

You can also read it as a PDF document, which looks much better in my opinion. I hate the styling in WordPress.

I'm pretty critical of all the Linux mobile device makers, but I also see a lot of hope for the future.
Feedback is welcome.

One certianly hopes so, for if not we have no escape, we perhaps bubbled the idea Linux phones too soon, but now that hardware is hard to find we are in a real need(Android side-load apocalypse) for said hardware. Post this to TMO as well.  https://talk.maemo.org/
  Reply
#3
(10-07-2026, 07:37 PM)amosbatto Wrote: I wrote in-depth article about whether Linux phones will become a viable alternative to the Android/iOS duopoly:

https://amosbbatto.wordpress.com/2026/10...ternative/

You can also read it as a PDF document, which looks much better in my opinion. I hate the styling in WordPress.

I'm pretty critical of all the Linux mobile device makers, but I also see a lot of hope for the future.
Feedback is welcome.

first i congratulate of this colossally long article. shorten it by 99%! or maybe 99.9%!

maybe provide a summary, but even the summary cannot be too long, i think maximum of 5000 characters.

you definitely surpassed following articles by length, which are already super long. 

https://dustycloud.org/blog/how-decentra...s-bluesky/
https://dustycloud.org/blog/re-re-bluesk...alization/

super short summary for previous two articles:
bluesky is not decentralized enough.

Quote:Customers who received the Librem 5 were able to resell it for more than they paid,

this tells something about linux market these days.

Quote:As noted in my article on LineageOS statistics, the brands which have good policies for bootloader unlocking has shrunk from 42.5% to about 7% of the global smartphone market over the last couple years.

this is a bad trend, and i think i gets worse in the future. but i also learned i recent years that even if bootloader is oem unlocked, it still has some limitations. like, oem drivers must be signed by a signing key somewhere inside cpu. and first phase of android bootloader is still controlled by manufacturer. it also forces android partitioning.

i am somewhat hopeful that something comes up in the future for mobile linux, and good news is that whole work doesn't need to be start from the scratch. we roughly speaking have user interfaces and operating systems, so we need devices.

one giant headache is some critical apps, like banking apps or bad 2fa apps, which require android with closed components or ios. even if mobile linux works perfectly, it cannot fix if some company forces users to use closed platforms and devices.

as a some kind of backup plan. i ended up with technical basic phone which has volte. most stuff i do with linux laptops. at the moment i don't need any critical apps, so i could live without android at the moment. although i bought one android device, which can be unlocked, and can be installed with linux using android kernel, although in early testing stages. but for now i use that android device for lineageos, if i need some android things. i also want to know what's going on in android world, like rooting, bootloader, magisk and so on.
  Reply
#4
Another issue is if the telco network provider only whitelists certain phones.

If they block your phone for voice then you have to use VOIP over 4g data for calls.(I use VOIP for calls anyway, but one of my banks will not allow the SMS from my VOIP provider to be used for authorization!)

It would be handy if there existed a generic flat 4g hotspot device that I could just clamp to the back of whatever Linux wifi device I choose. Even my dumbphone is too bulky to carry along with a separate Linux device.

So I end up using old Motorola and Samsung phone but replaced the stock Android with /e/os.


Maybe future pinephone could be simplified by using off the shelf module like the Mecha Comet is doing, if voice network access is restrictive anyway.


https://mecha.so/comet/lte-support
  Reply
#5
(10-07-2026, 07:37 PM)amosbatto Wrote: I wrote in-depth article about whether Linux phones will become a viable alternative to the Android/iOS duopoly:

https://amosbbatto.wordpress.com/2026/10...ternative/

You can also read it as a PDF document, which looks much better in my opinion. I hate the styling in WordPress.

I'm pretty critical of all the Linux mobile device makers, but I also see a lot of hope for the future.
Feedback is welcome.

now i have to ask. did you use a.i. to generate this article? and possibly, how much and how?

i'm not a giant fan of a.i., so if someone uses it, at least tells it is a.i. generated, or a.i. helped creating it.
  Reply
#6
>now i have to ask. did you use a.i. to generate this article? and possibly, how much and how?


I am not the author, but the article includes personal experience by the author, including wiki contributions, ventures into side-issues and obscure historical details, author shows a track record of not being afraid of doing non-trivial research, plus provides thorough references.

So, no, I doubt it, but either way it was a pretty comprehensive article about the history and prospects of linux phones, especially as it pertains to trying to duplicate the functionality expected of popular smartphones.

I think the three possible avenues suggested ignored a couple of other, admittedly unlikely options:

1) Some large governnent entity i.e. EU subsidizes a massive europhone project, possibly on homegrown RISC-V silicon. This has side benefit of getting out from under superpower control, fingerprinting, etc.

2) A geeky shift towards low-bandwith no-javascript communication protocols, where less powerful phones like the Mecha Comet are accepted as adequate.
edit (not to imply the Mecha is not capable. The SOC ISP has support for FOSS as well :  https://community.nxp.com/t5/i-MX-Proces...anguage=en

edit2 also it seems only the imx95 version would be capable of 4k video encoding, according to google gemini. This is in reference to the article:
>"Because the Librem 5’s i.MX 8M Quad processor lacks an ISP, audio DSP and hardware video encoder, it takes roughly 10 times as long to process and encode a 720p video on the Librem 5 as the length of the video, and it’s about 50 times longer on the PinePhone, due to its antiquated Allwinner A64 processor and significantly slower RAM and eMMC."

Also the relative benchmarks of the imx95 are superior to those of the Pinephone Pro's RK3399 (350/1300 vs 278/708). So if PPP overall performance was acceptable, then so should the imx95's. And power consumption is hopefully better than the RK3588, as google gemini implies.
* apparently just having a video encoder did not automatically translate to good performance for the PPP:
https://jellyfin.org/docs/general/post-i.../rockchip/
  Reply
#7
I was critical of PINE64 in my article. In particular, I wrote:
Quote:Most of the volunteer developers stopped collaborating with PINE64, so the community-based company didn’t have the manpower to do the necessary software development for its new hardware. Most distros weren’t willing to work on a phone that couldn’t even properly boot. Thousands of people bought the PinePhone Pro after it was released in December 2021, expecting that eventually it would become a functional device, but it still had major software problems when its sales were cancelled in August 2025. The failure of the PinePhone Pro illustrates that PINE64 had its priorities backwards by focusing on one distro that mainly does packaging work, rather than focusing on the booting and kernel work.
Ondřej Jirman (aka “mega”, “megi” or “megous”), who has done a lot of kernel work on the PINE64 devices, criticized these statements on Hacker News, as “so much Pine64-bashing and quite a lot of factual errors.” You can read our back and forth here.

I don't own the PinePhone Pro and my assessment of the software on the PinePhone Pro was based on what is publicly listed on the PINE64 wiki about the device, but Jirman says that the wiki is wrong. Since I can’t find much info online, I want some independent verification of what Jirman is saying, before I change what I stated in my article.

I know that many of you here own the PinePhone Pro. Can you please let me know your evaluation of the software on the PinePhone Pro and whether you think the software problems listed on the wiki have been fixed. Do you think my criticisms of PINE64 in the article are accurate or not? 

Thanks in advance.
  Reply
#8
(10-09-2026, 11:29 AM)zetabeta Wrote: first i congratulate of this colossally long article. shorten it by 99%! or maybe 99.9%!

maybe provide a summary,
I stopped writing when I got to 30 pages, and decided to wrap it up. I tried to summarize the basic argument in the introduction, but several people have told me to add a summary so it is easier to digest. I went into detail, because there is so much stuff that most people don't understand about the engineering and software challenges that face Linux phones, even among people who own the phones.

Quote:one giant headache is some critical apps, like banking apps or bad 2fa apps, which require android with closed components or ios. even if mobile linux works perfectly, it cannot fix if some company forces users to use closed platforms and devices.

Yes. Linux phones need support for Android apps in order to succeed, and the current state of Waydroid and microG is not good in my opinion. Waydroid is still stuck with AOSP 13/LineageOS 20, and only now are they starting to upgrade it to AOSP 16/LineageOS 23. The banking app from my bank requires AOSP 15 or later and currently won't work in Waydroid. I detest the fact that GrapheneOS's solution is a sandboxed Google Play Services, but I can also understand why they went with that solution over microG. We need a FOSS solution for Android apps that can pass the Play Integrity and rooted checks. 

Quote:now i have to ask. did you use a.i. to generate this article? and possibly, how much and how?

I didn't use any AI when writing the article except for what Google and DuckDuckGo automatically shows when you do a web search. 

I have never tried using Claude before, and I wondered how good it is, so this morning I asked it, "Can you correct the grammar errors in my article?" It found about 30 errors in the article. I accepted about 25 out of the 30 suggestions from Claude. Most of it was stupid stuff that I should have caught, like singular verbs not matching plural subjects or forgetting words (the, a/an, of, etc.). It did point how that I got the year wrong when Nokia started using Windows in its phones. So I edited my article this morning to fix those problems. 

So if you read the article before today, there was no A.I influence, but now there is some A.I. influence. ;-)
  Reply
#9
(10-14-2026, 12:57 PM)amosbatto Wrote:
Quote:one giant headache is some critical apps, like banking apps or bad 2fa apps, which require android with closed components or ios. even if mobile linux works perfectly, it cannot fix if some company forces users to use closed platforms and devices.

Yes. Linux phones need support for Android apps in order to succeed, and the current state of Waydroid and microG is not good in my opinion. Waydroid is still stuck with AOSP 13/LineageOS 20, and only now are they starting to upgrade it to AOSP 16/LineageOS 23. The banking app from my bank requires AOSP 15 or later and currently won't work in Waydroid. I detest the fact that GrapheneOS's solution is a sandboxed Google Play Services, but I can also understand why they went with that solution over microG. We need a FOSS solution for Android apps that can pass the Play Integrity and rooted checks. 

let's take this first, others later.

this is something i disagree, or having totally different direction. i essentially think that android is a lost cause, that includes "android open source project", usually aosp. too much alphabet inc in it messing it up. it is a matter of time when alphabet inc finalizes takeover of android and everything is controlled by central master. roughly speaking only thing is needed is forcing manufacturers to use locked bootloaders, and those bootloaders load google components, which cannot be turned off.

my solution is more like open generic application platform or open web protocols, companies and banks use those open protocols, without forcing any specific operating system. many things can be done with website and it is platform independent. some things require an app or access to some operating system functions, but creating platform independent application system can resolve those issues. basically solution comes from outside of android and ios.

https://keepandroidopen.org/  is a delaying tactic at best.

where is alphabet inc or google, there is a problem.
  Reply
#10
(10-07-2026, 07:37 PM)amosbatto Wrote: Feedback is welcome.

i think there are some errors. but i take it from my memory, so accuracy is low.

Quote:... and the fact that PINE64 had shifted from sharing revenue with many distros to only paying Manjaro, ...

it is true that pine org donated 10$ per device in branded batches for development, there is a blog post somewhere. however, in my knowledege this did not continue in beta edition and later.

Quote:It split off its hardware operations into a separate company named Jolla-Devices, which sells now Sony smartphones with Sailfish OS preinstalled to the European market, plus Volla Phones with Ubuntu Touch and Pixels with GrapheneOS.

this was changed later. in my knowledge, jolla never sold pixel phones or volla phones. although sailfish was available for some sony devices.
  Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Article: The Advantages of mobile Linux over AOSP amosbatto 2 853 10-20-2026, 02:38 PM
Last Post: zetabeta
  How to install Android on SOQuartz Lenzer 2 4,511 08-14-2026, 01:36 AM
Last Post: winpkr
  Looking for PineTime users to test an Android app with BLE heart rate support Mitrax 2 3,003 03-11-2026, 02:50 PM
Last Post: Mitrax
  Has anyone installed Trisquel (linux-libre) on Pine64 RockPro64? libreboy 1 4,895 11-03-2025, 12:08 PM
Last Post: RandB
  [article] Linux Phone Takeover Juergen 4 7,220 10-08-2025, 02:31 PM
Last Post: zech.dexos
  [Article] RISC-V Ox64 BL808: UART Interrupt and Platform-Level Interrupt Controller lupyuen 2 13,102 09-03-2025, 10:51 PM
Last Post: PrinceMorissette
  google will take control of android in the future. zetabeta 22 24,864 08-25-2025, 03:14 PM
Last Post: zetabeta
  [Article] Creating the Unicorn Emulator for Avaota-A1 SBC (Apache NuttX RTOS) lupyuen 0 3,826 04-12-2025, 06:04 PM
Last Post: lupyuen
  [Article] Porting Apache NuttX RTOS to Avaota-A1 SBC (Allwinner A527 SoC) lupyuen 2 5,257 03-22-2025, 07:30 PM
Last Post: lupyuen
  [Article] StarPro64 EIC7700X RISC-V SBC: Maybe LLM on NPU on NuttX? lupyuen 2 5,793 03-08-2025, 09:20 PM
Last Post: tllim

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)