Article: The Advantages of mobile Linux over AOSP
#1
After I posted my article, Will Linux phones become a viable alternative to the Android/iOS duopoly? (see on this forum), quite a few people in other forums (r/linux, Hacker News, etc.) commented that it made no sense to develop mobile Linux, when we already have AOSP, which is a Linux distro. I wrote this article in response:

https://amosbbatto.wordpress.com/2026/10...over-aosp/

Feedback is welcome.
  Reply
#2
Another informative and comprehensive article!

So you're saying it's too daunting to keep up with the milliions of lines of code (and exclusionary, proprietary forks) that Google gradually introduces. But in the 2nd to last paragraph:

>"Chipmakers have to create separate drivers for Android and Linux. Sadly, the makers of mobile systems-on-a-chip (Qualcomm Snapdragon, MediaTek Dimensity, UNISOC Tiger, Samsung Exynos and Xiaomi Xring) have chosen to support Android, but not Linux, which is why AOSP phones generally have much better performance than phones."


So conversely, it is _also_ daunting* for Linux (as opposed to AOSP) to keep up with changing hardware!
* See PinephonePro


Since it takes so long to catch up to the hardware, while software layers such as android emulation are in continuous expansion, it sounds like a futile mission of catch-up to support all those millions of android apps.


Therefore, I feel this is crying out for a third article, if you are interested: Why the Linux Phone's Best Hope Is As A Dumbphone


And then maybe even a fourth: The Linux Phone On An Open Source Hardware SOC Is Would Be Powerful Enough For A Dumbphone
  Reply
#3
(10-19-2026, 11:31 AM)amosbatto Wrote: After I posted my article, Will Linux phones become a viable alternative to the Android/iOS duopoly? (see on this forum), quite a few people in other forums (r/linux, Hacker News, etc.) commented that it made no sense to develop mobile Linux, when we already have AOSP, which is a Linux distro. I wrote this article in response:

https://amosbbatto.wordpress.com/2026/10...over-aosp/

Feedback is welcome.

on early days of android, roughly in 2010, i basically believed android was linux or linux distribution. in a way that android gets benefits of open source world. although i knew it has those closed components in that time, like google play services. in that time there was some alternate platforms like, sailfishos and windows, i thought number of apps was criteria and therefore those alternate platforms were usually doomed to fail.

now in 2020 era, i think android is abuse of linux by alphabet inc. ios is also abuse of freebsd by apple. relying on android even in un-googled way is giving control to google and not a long-term solution.

https://keepandroidopen.org/  is a delaying tactic at best. but it is needed for short term though, because of some critical apps, like banking app and transportation app.

followings is to comment those borrowed comments in the article:

linux mobile has fewer apps, yes. but most apps are open source, whereas ios and google play have lot of closed source apps with questionable motives, usually data collection and spying. so, fairer comparison is f-droid apps.

linux mobile already has surprisingly many apps for basic usage, plus you get those desktop apps, even though user interface is little clunky.

linux apps are built differently, they accumulate over time. so, start is the difficult part, continuation not so much.

i theorized some kind of mobile application platform. where application is built, it can run on most operating systems where mobile platform is installed, like android, ios, sailfish. it is similar to flatpak or appimage, which is distribution independent.

many things can be done through web browser using web engine technologies. separate app is not required, but many companies forces their app anyway.

finally:

basically i think that, aosp is not a long term solution, alphabet inc will cripple it somehow. android is not linux in a sense of open source idea and transparent development.

Quote:They want to install packages directly from AUR?

! arch user repository, i want that malware infested aur, it gives linux kind street credibility!
  Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Article: Will Linux phones become a viable alternative to the Android/iOS duopoly? amosbatto 11 2,592 10-19-2026, 09:52 AM
Last Post: amosbatto
  Has anyone installed Trisquel (linux-libre) on Pine64 RockPro64? libreboy 1 4,899 11-03-2025, 12:08 PM
Last Post: RandB
  [article] Linux Phone Takeover Juergen 4 7,234 10-08-2025, 02:31 PM
Last Post: zech.dexos
  [Article] RISC-V Ox64 BL808: UART Interrupt and Platform-Level Interrupt Controller lupyuen 2 13,106 09-03-2025, 10:51 PM
Last Post: PrinceMorissette
  [Article] Creating the Unicorn Emulator for Avaota-A1 SBC (Apache NuttX RTOS) lupyuen 0 3,826 04-12-2025, 06:04 PM
Last Post: lupyuen
  [Article] Porting Apache NuttX RTOS to Avaota-A1 SBC (Allwinner A527 SoC) lupyuen 2 5,261 03-22-2025, 07:30 PM
Last Post: lupyuen
  [Article] StarPro64 EIC7700X RISC-V SBC: Maybe LLM on NPU on NuttX? lupyuen 2 5,794 03-08-2025, 09:20 PM
Last Post: tllim
  [Article] Test Bot for NuttX Pull Requests ... Tested on Real Hardware (Oz64 SG2000) lupyuen 0 3,535 02-15-2025, 11:26 AM
Last Post: lupyuen
  Is the Linux mobile phone still developing? CleanEnvironment 5 6,034 08-07-2024, 06:25 PM
Last Post: KC9UDX
  [Article] RISC-V Emulator for Pine64 Oz64 SBC lupyuen 2 5,142 07-07-2024, 04:19 AM
Last Post: lupyuen

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)